加载中...
Visa-Free Entry Policies and Foreign Direct Investment: Evidence from Firm Registration Data
中国逐步扩大普通护照免签安排,作为推进高水平制度型开放、便利跨境人员往来并在全球经济不确定性中稳定外资的重要举措。在此背景下,本文关注一个关键问题:短期跨境人员流动便利化能否转化为实际外资进入?本文将中国自2023年以来分批实施的免签入境政策视为准自然实验,估计其对外商直接投资(FDI)的因果效应。利用全国工商企业注册数据,本文构建了2023年1月至2026年2月城市—来源国—行业—月份层面新设外商独资企业的面板数据,并采用多期双重差分(DID)框架进行因果识别。实证策略利用政策实施时点的跨国差异外生性来识别投资对签证便利化的响应。研究发现,免签政策显著增加了符合条件来源国新设外资企业的注册数量,该结果在经过一系列识别与稳健性检验后依然成立。机制分析指出政策发挥作用的三个不同渠道:第一,释放持续开放的可信承诺信号,强化政策连续性预期;第二,改善中国周边国际舆论环境;第三,通过促进面对面接触和信息流动缓解跨境软信息摩擦,从而减轻投资决策中的信息不对称。处理效应呈现有意义的异质性:在事前人员往来和国际航空联系更发达、投资项目规模更大、来源国与中国时区差异更小、行业资本密集度更高、双边移民网络更广泛以及服务业外资进入中效应更强。进一步分析发现,政策效应在事前对华出口联系更强、历史投资基础更深厚来源国—城市—行业单元中尤为显著。综合来看,这些模式表明,签证便利化在加速市场情报、商业关系或初步投资意向已经建立的潜在项目落地方面具有特别功效。本文对文献做出三方面贡献:第一,从跨境人员流动视角考察外商直接投资的决定因素,利用普通护照免签政策的分批实施并结合全国工商注册数据,提供短期跨境流动如何影响外资进入的微观证据,拓展了FDI决定因素研究的前沿;第二,推进了签证政策投资效应的制度解释,表明免签入境通过政策信号、外部信息环境改善和信息不对称降低三个相互关联机制促进外资,拓宽了理解短期跨境流动经济后果的分析框架;第三,为评估最新一轮普通护照免签安排提供了新证据,并为完善免签入境政策设计和加强配套制度基础设施提供实证基础。除直接政策含义外,这些发现为加强国际传播、改善入境后商务服务、促进投资对接以及协调签证便利化与国际航空联系提供了实践指导。
Abstract
China has progressively expanded visa-free entry for ordinary passport holders as part of its broader strategy to advance high-standard institutional opening-up, facilitate cross-border mobility, and anchor foreign investment amid global economic uncertainty. Against this backdrop, a critical question emerges: does liberalising short-term cross-border movement translate into tangible foreign investment entry? This paper addresses this question by treating the staggered roll-out of China's visa-free entry policy since 2023 as a quasi-natural experiment and estimating its causal effect on inward foreign direct investment (FDI). Utilising comprehensive nationwide business registration data, a city–source country–industry–month panel of newly established wholly foreign-owned enterprises spanning January 2023 to February 2026 is constructed, and a staggered difference-in-differences (DID) framework is employed for causal identification. The empirical strategy exploits exogenous cross-country variation in the timing of policy adoption to isolate the investment response to visa liberalisation. The empirical findings demonstrate that the visa-free entry policy significantly increases the incidence of new foreign-invested enterprise registrations from eligible source countries, a result that withstands an extensive battery of identification and robustness checks. The mechanism analysis points to three distinct channels through which the policy operates: first, by signalling a credible commitment to continued openness and reinforcing expectations of policy durability; second, by enhancing the international discursive environment surrounding China; and third, by mitigating cross-border soft-information frictions through the facilitation of face-to-face contacts and information flows, thereby attenuating informational asymmetries in investment decisions. The treatment effect exhibits meaningful heterogeneity. It is amplified where pre-policy people-to-people exchanges and international air connectivity were more developed, for larger-scale investment projects, for source economies with smaller time-zone differentials relative to China, in industries with higher capital intensity, where bilateral diaspora networks are more extensive, and notably, for foreign entry into service sectors. A further exploration reveals that the policy effect is particularly pronounced in source-country–city–industry cells characterised by stronger antecedent export ties to China and a more substantial historical investment footprint. Collectively, these patterns suggest that visa liberalisation operates with particular efficacy in accelerating the materialisation of prospective projects for which market intelligence, commercial relationships, or preliminary investment inclinations have already been established. This paper makes three distinct contributions to the literature. First, it examines the determinants of foreign direct investment through the lens of cross-border personnel mobility. By exploiting the staggered roll-out of the ordinary-passport visa-waiver policy and combining it with comprehensive nationwide business registration data, the paper furnishes micro-level evidence on how short-term cross-border mobility influences foreign investment entry, thereby extending the frontier of research on FDI determinants beyond conventional economic and institutional factors. Second, it advances an institutional account of the investment effects of visa policy. The analysis demonstrates that visa-free entry promotes foreign investment through three interrelated mechanisms – policy signalling, improvements in the external information environment, and reductions in information asymmetry – thus broadening the analytical framework for understanding the economic consequences of short-term cross-border movement. Third, it offers novel evidence for evaluating the latest round of ordinary-passport visa-free arrangements and provides empirical foundations for refining the design of visa-free entry policies and enhancing their complementary institutional infrastructure. Beyond the immediate policy implications, these findings offer practical guidance for strengthening international communication, improving post-entry business services, facilitating investment matching, and aligning visa facilitation with international air connectivity.
免签政策显著增加免签国家在华新设外资企业数量
基准回归中DID系数为0.185,在1%水平上显著为正,表明免签政策实施后,来自享受免签入境国家的新设外资企业数量相比其他国家显著增加。被解释变量为城市—行业—来源国—月份层面新设外商独资企业数量的对数。
政策信号渠道:免签提高来源地对华信息关注度并强化制度距离较大样本的引资效应
以Google Trends中国主题搜索热度为被解释变量,DID系数为3.132且显著为正;DID与制度距离交互项为0.152且显著,说明来源地与中国的制度差异越大,免签政策的投资促进作用越强,验证政策信号机制。
国际舆情渠道:免签改善涉华报道语调并促进外资进入
以GDELT新闻情感语调Avgtone为被解释变量,DID系数为0.819且显著为正;将Avgtone匹配至城市—行业—月份层面后其系数为0.016且显著为正,滞后1期系数为0.018,说明国际舆情改善稳定促进外资进入。
信息不对称渠道:行业面对面沟通依赖越高,免签政策引资效应越强
DID与行业公众互动依赖度Ftf_wpp交互项为0.040且显著为正,与外部客户接触需求Ftf_extcust交互项为0.061、与面对面交流频率Ftf_f2f交互项为0.036均显著为正,表明沟通需求提高1个标准差,免签政策效应边际增强。
异质性:人员往来基础好、投资规模大、时区差异小、资本密集度高及服务业样本效应更显著
高人员往来强度组DID系数为0.286,低组为-0.023;大规模投资组为0.297,小规模组为0.083;DID与时区差异交互项为-0.055;与资本密集度交互项为0.122;服务业系数为0.160,制造业为0.018。
加快潜在项目落地:事前对华出口联系和投资基础越强,政策效应越大
DID与事前对华出口规模交互项为0.121、与出口份额交互项为0.075、与出口商品多样性交互项为0.070,均显著为正;与历史投资基础fdi_pre交互项为0.094,说明免签降低沟通成本,加快既有机会向实际投资转化。
核心解释变量
免签政策(DID):若中国对来源国c在t月实施普通护照免签则取1,否则取0;政策数据由作者根据国务院和国家移民管理局官方公告手工收集,涵盖单方面免签与双边互免安排
被解释变量
城市p在t月来自国家c且属于行业i的新设外商独资企业数量的对数(ln ifdi);数据来自企查查全国工商企业注册信息,时间范围为2023年1月至2026年2月
样本与数据
2023年1月至2026年2月全国新设外商独资企业注册数据,构建城市—来源国—行业—月份面板;剔除成立后转为外商独资、分支机构、港澳地区及关键信息缺失样本;基准回归不包含零值观测,有效观测15131个
识别方法 / 模型设定
多期双重差分(Staggered DID),控制城市—月份、行业—月份、城市—国家—行业固定效应及前定国家特征与月份固定效应交互项;事件研究法检验平行趋势;标准误聚类至国家层面;采用de Chaisemartin and d'Haultfoeuille(2020)、Callaway and Sant'Anna(2021)、Sun and Abraham(2021)等方法处理异质性处理效应
内生性及稳健性检验
平行趋势检验、异质性处理效应诊断、遗漏变量控制(国家线性趋势、国家—年份固定效应、欧洲—月份固定效应、月度汇率与CPI)、安慰剂检验(随机处理组与政策时点500次)、PSM-DID(1:1最近邻、1:3最近邻、Kernel匹配)、替换被解释变量为注册资本总额、剔除空壳企业、剔除避税天堂来源资本、剔除新签投资协定国家及俄乌白样本、控制海底光缆和过境免签等同期因素、前移样本起点至2021和2022年
中国工商企业进入退出信息统计数据
企业进入退出可支持的研究问题:免签政策实施前后,中国各省份外资企业注册数量与存续状态是否出现显著变化,其效应在不同行业与省份间是否存在异质性。
机场航班信息数据
航线可支持的研究问题:免签入境政策是否通过提升国际航空连通性促进了外商直接投资?基于国内城市出发的航班信息数据,可构建城市-年度层面的国际航线数量与航班频次指标,检验免签政策实施后航空连通性的中介效应。
中外双边贸易数据
双边贸易可支持的研究问题:可用于比较政策前后贸易流量变动;进一步地,双边贸易的国别差异是否调节了免签政策对外商直接投资的影响。
O*NET美国职业岗位特征数据
职业分类可支持的研究问题:基于O*NET中管理、销售、专业技术等职业的技能与工作活动维度,能否识别出免签政策对依赖高频人员往来的行业的外资企业注册概率具有更强促进效应。